Mass Wasting and Planetary Surface Processes

Behavior & Dynamics of geophysical granular flows

*/ PhD : Doctorate School ED-109 IPGP/P7 Sciences de la Terre et de l'Univers, Espace.
  Advisors: Anne Mangeney (IPGP) - Daniel Mège (LPGN)

Science Topics
  • Geomorphology of Mass Wasting processes on tellurics planets (e.g. Earth, Mars)
  • Modeling of geophysical flows (landslide, debris flows, gullies...)
  • Dynamics and behavior of granular flows
  • Remote Sensing and GIS (Multispectral data in visible and IR, DTM, mozaicking, calibration, classification...)

Landquake - Seismic waves generated by landslide, feedback to dynamics



A 2.5Mm3 of rocky mass has been released on the 18th of September 2004. The observed runout is about 2km. On the avalanche path, the presence of a glacier make this example interesting for dynamics analysis. Furthermore, some seismic records of this event have been performed.

Numerical simulation of the rock avalanche respectively without glacier and with glacier taken into consideration. Landslides can generate seismic waves. By comparing recorded and simulated signals generated by landslides new insigths dynamics can be performed on granular flows. In addition, this is a powerful tool for model validation.

Seismic record of Thurwieser rock avalanche at Fuorn Station (Data provided by University of Milano , Italia, G. Crosta).

Comparison between records (in red) and modelisation (green and blues). The presence of a glacier on the avalanche path has huge impact on dynamics and thuson generated seismic waves. Modelisation without glacier (green) does not fit all mouvment of the ground whereas modelisation with glacier taken into consideration (blue curve) has a good match with recorded data.
This study shows how seismic signal can give informations on dynamics of landslide and how it could be a good tool for numerical model validation.


Some references:

P. Favreau; A. Mangeney; A. Lucas, N. M. Shapiro; , G. B. Crosta; F. Bouchut, LANDSLIDE AND SEISMIC WAVES , GRL,2010.
P. Favreau; A. Mangeney; A. Lucas, N. M. Shapiro; G. B. Crosta; F. Bouchut ; O. Hungr,Numerical modeling of landslide generated seismic waves. AGU 2009.



Behavior & Mobility of Large Martians landslides


Recent experiments on dry granular flows over horizontal plane bare some similarities with large Martian landslides observed in Valles Marineris (VM). However, Martian normalized runout are twice as large as those that observed in dry granular flow experiments. Numerical simulations on theoretical 2D and real 3D topographies reconstructed from remote sensing data show that slope effects significantly reduce the shift between experimental results and Martian observation. However, topography effects are not strong enough to explain the high mobility of Martian landslides. As a result, other physical and/or geological processes should play a key role into the dynamics of Martian landslides. A new mobility is defined that makes it possible to characterize the dynamics of the flow regardless of the geometry of the released mass and of the underlying topography.


Some references:

A. Lucas
, and A. Mangeney, Mobility and topographic effects for large Valles Marineris landslides on Mars, Geophys. Res. Lett.,2007.

A. Lucas, A. Mangeney, D. Mège, Bouchut, F. On the mobility of large Martian landslides. Workshop on Martian Gullies : Theory and tests 2008.
A. Lucas and A. Mangeney. Mobility and topographic effects for large Valles Marineris landslides on Mars. AGU Fall Meeting, 2007.

Landslide initial conditions and spreading effects

Landslides take part in weathering and transport processes on Earth as well as on Mars. Prediction of their dynamic remains awkward in spite of many experimental and numerical studies. Numerous numerical works have been carry out on real landslides cases using DTM (Digital Topographic Model) so as to improve our understanding of the behavior by comparing results with field observations. Generally, previously studies are based on runout analysis dealing with mean dissipation calibration such as friction coefficient. Nevertheless, the shape of the initial scarp is generally unknown for real cases. It is perilous in this context to get good predictions of spreading in a given geological setting. We thus tried here to clear up the potential error on mean dissipation because of the uncertainty related to the unkown geometry of the initial scarp. In addition, from the field observations of final stage (e.g. landslide's deposits) we tried to get feeback on initial conditions such as geometry and volume of mass involved. This study is focused on the effect of the scarp geometry on the spreading flow using a numerical model able to take into account the curvature matrix of the bottom topography. Using these capabilities, a benchmarking analysis involving theorical scarp geometries (e.g. 2D and 3D) have been performed. We then combined a geomorphological analysis on real cases. Our results show that the runout distance is not affected by the initial shape of the scarp, whatever the friction coefficient. Otherwise, we observed on 3D tests that the shape of the final deposits is a function of the scarp geometry. As consequences, from final deposits, we are able to get information on both, initial geometries and initial volume involved in the mass spreading. We validated these results with terrestrial examples for which the scarp geometry and friction coefficient are well known. then, as from these results, we tried to apply a feedback analysis on Martian landslides. We get good agreement between geomorphological analysis and modeling, allowing us to explore deeper in initial conditions of landslides on Mars. As conlusions, we developped a feedback analysis process able to give information on volume and shape of the initial mass involved in landslides.



 Some references:

A. Lucas, A. Mangeney, D. Mège, F. Bouchut. Landslide Scar Geometry Effect on Flow Spreading: Application to Martian Landslides.Lunar and Planetary Science XXXX,2009.
A. Lucas, A. Mangeney, D. Mège, K. Kelfoun,. New Methodology for Initial Volume Estimation of Martian Landslides from DTM and Imagery.Workshop on Martian Gullies : Theory and tests 2008.
A. Lucas, A. Mangeney, D. Mège, F. Bouchut, Implications of the landslide scarp geometry on the flow spreading: Application on Terrestrial and Martian landslides,AGU Fall Meeting 2008.



Dynamics of Martian Gullies



Recently, bright gully deposits observed by MOC images were subject to debate on their formation. Initialy interpreted as evidence of liquid water, this flow was modeled and thought to be dry based on geomorphics features. The granular rheology is able to reproduce the ”fingers” features observed on the natural example. We focus here on the Centauri Montes example (96oE,-38oN). The deposits are 600 m long and 35 m large and the source seems to be 400m above the upper part of the current deposits. Moreover, the topographic slope angle 12o at the front of the deposits. This point questions the value of the mean dissipation ( e.g. The friction angle δ describes the mean dissipation in granular flow) of the gully and thus the behavior of the flow. Indeed, granular media starts to flow when the slope reaches the avalanche angle θa and stops when this slope gets repose angle θr. Consequently, hysteresis of granular flows occurs when the slope angle θ ∈ [θa; θr]. In this manner, the friction angle of material involved should be very small (δ < 12o) regarding to classical values measured experimentally (e.g. friction angle of sand is ~30o). However, the slope angle at the hypothetical source is above 40o. Assuming a dry granular behavior, we can question if the inertia is strong enough allowing the mass flowing down below a 20o slope? Using an up-to-date numerical model, the aim of this study is to go into the dynamics of such mass flows, so as to figure out the balance of forces that occured during the flowing of dry granular media.


 


Some references:

N. Mangold, A. Mangeney, D. Baratoux, A. Lucas, F. Bouchut, Analogy Between Gullies on Mars and on Earth: What similarities? What differences? International Conference on Comparative Planetology: Venus – Earth – Mars, 2009.
A. Lucas, A. Mangeney, N. Mangold, D. Mège, F. Bouchut. New insights into the dynamics of Martian gullies. Lunar and Planetary Science XXXX, 2009.


Genetic links between outflows and chasmata on Valles Marineris Plateau, Mars


Within the Valles Marineris region on Mars, a huge system of interconnected valleys interpreted as flood channels reveals the presence of braided channels and strong incisions into the bedrock. We focus our study on Ganges Chasma, where two examples of outflow channels lie on the Valles Marineris plateau and take source in depressions. These channels may represent good examples for studying the relationship between the formation of Chasmata and outflow channels. No mass deposition is observed at the mouth of both channels, indicating that outflows were active before the opening of Ganges Chasma. In addition, possible sapping valleys were formed at the mouth in both cases. Residual aquifer could have been responsible for a late hydrogeological activity in this region after the opening and the widening of Ganges Chasma. From these observations and our flux calculations, we concludet hat overpressure due to dyke ascent could have initiated outflows on Valles Marineris plateau, which is consistent with previous studies. Our results suggest that these mechanisms played a role in the opening and the widening of the Chasmata around 3 to 3.5 Gy.



 Some references:

A. Lucas, V. Ansan, N. Mangold, New insight on genetic links between outflows and chasmata on Valles Marineris plateau, Mars. Géomorphologie: relief, processus, environnement. Vol 1. 2009.